• dan@upvote.au
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    edit-2
    15 hours ago

    In the US and EU, copyright law only recognizes human authorship. Fully AI-generated (“vibe-coded”) content, including source code, can’t be licensed at all even under an open-source license, and has to be public domain. AI code is only copyrightable if it’s just used as an assistant to a human, not vibe coded.

    The fact that you wrote a prompt to output the code doesn’t mean anything. The prompt is considered an idea, and ideas aren’t copyrightable - only the actual implementation of the idea is.

    Even if that wasn’t the case, it’s risky referring to AI-generated code as FOSS, since there’s no guarantee that the output it gave you wasn’t the result of it being trained on a proprietary codebase. This also means that vibe coded clones of proprietary software are on very shaky legal ground. There’s no way to prove that the AI model didn’t use proprietary information from the commercial software.

    Clean room reverse engineering also still needs two actual people (or two teams) in order to do it in a compliant way. One to write a spec based on behavior of the original program, and another that never looks at anything from the original app and builds the new software purely based on the spec. AI can assist, but it can’t just be one person using two different agents.

    • b3nsn0w@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      6 hours ago

      technically anything that’s public domain and has the source available is permissive open source by definition. most of these vibe coded projects get licensed under either mit or apache2, which are pretty good proxies for the same, so the end result is not that different to begin with.

    • ulterno@programming.dev
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      7 hours ago

      AI can assist, but it can’t just be one person using two different agents.

      Now that I think of it, one can just ask AI for the spec and then make their code from it, hence bypassing having to buy a single license that would be otherwise required for making the spec.