• Snowclone@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    6 days ago

    I used to be a priest, I took this all very seriously and studied it a lot, and I’m sorry to say but what your talking about as widely accepted historical fact is not correct. There’s no first hand accounts or eye witness accounts of Jesus’s ministry, the only texts we have are compilations of sayings and sermons from a wide verity of sources that Catholic scholars only attributed names to so people would know the general source, sources that were at the nearest maybe 20+ years afterwords, but much more likely 50+. Also Jesus’s divinity wasn’t a documented Christian belief until well after it became an established religion, and when it did come about it was heavily debated among leaders and scholars, and even today there are sects that reject Jesus’s divinity as part of the Christian faith. You are welcome to believe what you do, but there is a difference between your faith, and historical fact. Keep in mind also the history surrounding Christianity is almost exclusively the work of Christian scholars, not secular scholars, So saying it’s somehow biased to say Jesus’s divinity was not a belief in the early church, doesn’t work well as an argument when it’s modern Christian scholars that are saying this is the case. they have to take the data as important, not their personal faith, or it would just be a sermon of their own making and not historical information. you’re more than welcome to believe and have faith in whatever you choose, it’s not just historical fact.

    • HM King Charles III DG FD@feddit.uk
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      5 days ago

      The names were universally accepted, and most historical documents from that time are attributed. John’s Gospel even identified himself as the author. The attributions were never disputed, and wouldn’t make sense to be forgeries. Attribute them to the tax collector, and two minor people who are basically most notable for having the Gospels attributed to them, really?

      Jesus’ claims to be God in Mark’s Gospel - which is the first Gospel that is believed to have been written. St Paul also wrote even before then that Jesus is God.

      there are sects that reject Jesus’s divinity as part of the Christian faith.

      Notably Islam which claims to have a prophet who had it revealed to him in a cave, and Jehovah’s Witnesses who had to edit their bibles to say these things. Sure, there are other fringe sects from the restorationist movement, but there are also fringe sects which believe that some dude in Korea is the second coming of Christ.

      If a non-Christian scholar investigated the claims of Christianity and determined that they’re true, then it would be extremely strange if they didn’t become a Christian, hence a Christian scholar. Obviously if you’re a scholar arguing in favour of Christianity, you would be a Christian.

      I could say the same that the only scholars who are against Christianity are non-Christians and thus are clearly biased. That logic doesn’t work.